Page 1 of 1

I've returned whit new ships !(lionm12)

Posted: Fri May 11, 2012 9:28 pm
by lionm12
Yes I have returned,well I'm not even famous to make an entrance but what the heck.I have created a ship out of bordom.I don't know what to do whit my time so I've crawled back to Battelships.
:D

Re: I've returned whit new ships !(lionm12)

Posted: Fri May 11, 2012 10:33 pm
by JohnStar1456
Nice Ship, I don't see any wrong with but what the heck I know about. I'm just still a newbie

Re: I've returned whit new ships !(lionm12)

Posted: Sat May 12, 2012 6:44 pm
by DanDrester31
Nice Ship! Good Detail Bwt.

Re: I've returned whit new ships !(lionm12)

Posted: Sat May 12, 2012 8:35 pm
by Doogie12
The ships design is quite abstract, but it suffers from poor section usage. Its usually a given to NEVER mix standard sw sprites with shiny, ever. Keep practicing and look back at older ships

Re: I've returned whit new ships !(lionm12)

Posted: Sun May 13, 2012 12:05 am
by lionm12
I have made in my opinion a awsome ship,but maybe I did overuse the glow effect a little :| .Well please comment I am exited by what will you're comments be.

Re: I've returned whit new ships !(lionm12)

Posted: Sun May 13, 2012 3:27 am
by kittenpillar100
God, I hope we don't end up with another "This is the best and I don't care what you say user".

Its not awesome, the front doesn't look right at all: The girders connecting to the forward platforms are too spindily, the front ends abruptly and generally looks quite lazy. The bac is confusing blob of sections which isn't aesthetically pleasing whatsoever. The glow is not only overused, but ugly, and overall the aesthetics contrast horribly. Stick with one aesthetic (style) and base your ship around it. Forward planning with pencil and paper works. Sorry for being overly negative there. there are good points, you can definitely fit certain sections together quite well, and if you just stuck with a single aesthetic your ships'll look great.

Hope it helped!

Re: I've returned whit new ships !(lionm12)

Posted: Sun May 13, 2012 4:50 am
by lionm12
Ouch a little harsh there you don't need to rape me whit those words.I'm just trying my best.

Edit:Simple criticism would be nice.Example:Good, or not you don't need to write a book about it.

Re: I've returned whit new ships !(lionm12)

Posted: Wed May 16, 2012 6:21 am
by kittenpillar100
Oops, me being nasty again.

Sorry for coming off harsh there, I was just explaining my feeling towards your ships, I have put advice in there however, godd that you're trying your best, but I believe followig my advice will lead to better ships. This irked me though:
Simple criticism would be nice.Example:Good, or not you don't need to write a book about it.
Now, I believe tht that is not criticism, in fact it is but a single word. My 'book' as you say was a fairly simple paragraph explaining what I like and dislike about your spaceships, and how you could improve in my opinion. I didn't wish to offend you.

Sorry if I come off like a prat again.

Re: I've returned whit new ships !(lionm12)

Posted: Wed May 16, 2012 11:08 am
by Doogie12
Nope, kittenpillar is right. Neither of us directed any criticism at you, but to the creation whose criticism you asked for. You're even taking offense from a statement where he actually apologizes at the end in the case he sounds like a prat. Both of us know what we're saying as we are both experiencex with this.
That being said, I spot a few nifty tricks on the red one, but they come across as cheap gimmicks on a ship the likes of that. Apart from that, see kittenpillar's post.