Actually, Snopel, most of us have been around a bit longer than you. We know what we are talking about (most of the time

). If someone like Anna or Arcalane or any other long-standing members comment on your ships, then by god listen to them.
Now, as not to derail this thread:
Pyrophage, your first ship isnt actually too bad, and the color is actually somewhat nice, but it is severely lacking in depthing. try to work on that. Also, resizing weapons is a NO-NO. OTT, it looks pretty cool.
Your second ships are alright. First is a bit blocky, but it's not bad. The second one is fairly nice. I have no complaints about it.
Another thing, try and take your SM screenies in Preview mode. Just press F11.
Ed: Ninja'd by Anna xD
Ed2: Just realized the irony in that xD
I'm still alive, motherfuckers.