Page 1 of 2

A Blast From The Past - Talhydras's Druna Skas

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 3:48 am
by Anna
Image

Watch This Space. :lol:

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 4:17 am
by Dragontear
<s>De'ja vu in one day?</s>

X3

Lovely ship by the way.

Anna Edit: Arbitrary Rule #1) Never, ever, ever, post, link to, or even mention CtrlAltDel in Anna's Workshop, or so help me.

(Apologies, v.=.v' I didn't know that, and assumed that wasn't going to cause any ruckas.*Hides.*)

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 4:51 am
by Droid
I think this thread is for one of Talhydras's ships that Anna is remaking in TSwA style.

Promises to be epic.

Heard about it on IRC.

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 5:28 am
by Anna
Image

With the original colour scheme. I kinda like it but I know it's a little funky. A proper updated colour scheme is in the works presently. Here's some of what we've tried so far:

Image

Image

Image

More stuff to be done yet.

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 5:55 am
by Arcalane
Can't say I'm fond of the purple and green version personally, but that third recolour could probably be decent if the grey was lightened up and the blue brought out a little more. Not too much though.

You also missed a few bits. Spars around the center and such. ;)

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 6:13 am
by Kaelis
Talhydras is definitely one of the best shipbuilders and this was a spectacular ship back when he built it.

But...

Perhaps there is something wrong with me, but it doesn't blow me away the way it did back then. In fact, it doesn't blow me away at all; id even go as far as saying that im a bit sad how it turned out. Even that ship of yours you used in that retarded macro looks better to me.

Maybe its because it wasnt made with SW style in mind and looks flat and jumbled, or maybe my standards rose to ridiculous levels. Maybe it just needs some love. Maybe its just me, everyone else bows before this ship, and im just making a huge asshole out of myself here. I dunno, i just look at it and think that 'meh' would fit nicely to describe my feelings.

Or maybe the world is cruel and full of traps, there was a dream that you could only whisper, invading Iraq was a mistake, and bananas.

I think i need to lie down for a bit.

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 6:28 am
by Aralonia
Kaelis wrote:2.8 cuils
I personally think that this is just an example that building styles of the past mesh with the building styles of the new well, and that the overall quality of this wondrous ship has just increased in general.

Now I need to get off my ass and turn off my "EVERYTHING MUST BE LOGICAL" brain and make some damn beautiful ships.

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 6:33 am
by Siber
Kaelis wrote:Or maybe the world is cruel and full of traps, there was a dream that you could only whisper, invading Iraq was a mistake, and bananas.

I think i need to lie down for a bit.
Image


My own mind is a bit blown on two fronts here. Though I'm sure Talhydras could do better now, of course. He always comes back with something better when he picks the shipmaker back up after a while.

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 6:42 am
by Kaelis
Aralonia wrote:I personally think that this is just an example that building styles of the past mesh with the building styles of the new well, and that the overall quality of this wondrous ship has just increased in general.
Right, since your reading comprehension seems to be impaired, let me put it in simple terms:

I am not sure if my judgement is correct, therefore im being careful.

Sounds simple enough?

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 6:46 am
by Siber
Your not sure your judgment is correct, so you attack someone for contradicting your judgment? Well, I guess you are right about one thing, anyway.

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 6:52 am
by Anna
Talhydras has is own ideas for colouring, he just went monochrome and shaded the shit out of it, and is planning to add doodad stripes. Further updates will be later, since he disappeared to do stuff.

Image

Also, here's the original colour scheme with 10 times less "AHHH THOSE COLOURS ARE SO COLOURED".

Image

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 7:24 am
by Droid
Hmmm...

I think it's good, though the SM screenshot doesn't really do it justice. Normally, most ships have a lot of crisp-ness in SM-shots. This one doesn't because it has quite a few rotated sections to make its flowing hullform which leaves it a bit blurry in various places but not so much in others.

The in-game shot homogenizes the blur and looks far better.

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 7:56 am
by thanto_
I like the color schemes of the first and third recolor as is. The problem I see with it is the shading of the sections, specifically the lack thereof. While the sections and their arrangement imply depth/height differences, there's not enough shading to drive it home.


Talyhydras's shading does a much better job, though I see some areas for improvement in the 4x mirrored/repeated sections in the front which are repeated 3x around the sides. I don't know which section name that is, so that might be a little vague. Anyway, it's a little light on shading, not enough difference between them to imply a difference in height, which seems to be what it's attempting to convey with the way they're layered.


I like the detail on the rest of the shop though.

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 8:47 am
by Arcalane
That toned down recolour is much nicer, yes.

PS: Miscoloured a section just below the thingy in the middle!

Posted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 6:47 pm
by TheShipwrightArms
Ah, look at the craftmanship on that.

Have to say, the other sister ship Deathdealer is one of my all time favourites, maybe the all time favourite but this baby is pretty damn awesome. I love the design and the section work toward the aft.

It does look a little flat, but still, an excellent re-rendering of a brilliant ship.

Thanks to Anna.
Hats off to Talhydras.